Our Menu

First Pitch (Appetizers)

Garlic Knots
3 pieces. Fresh Italian bread hand-tied into knots and baked to perfection! Covered in our fresh garlic butter and sprinkled with imported Goat's milk Romano cheese. Served with your choice of marinara or ranch dipping sauce.
Naughty Knots
3 pieces. Fresh Italian bread hand-tied into knots and baked to perfection! Covered in our Tabasco and habañero garlic butter and sprinkled with imported Goat's milk Romano cheese. Served with your choice of marinara or ranch dipping sauce.
Boston-Style Hot Wings
8-10 pieces. Drummette and wing sections coated in our house Buffalo butter and sprinkled with grated parmesan.
Side of Home-made Meatball
Served with marinara, melted mozzarella, and shredded parmesan.
Side of Italian Sausage and Peppers
Hearty, very slightly spicy italian sausage served with peppers and onions cooked with olive oil and garlic,

East Coast Grinders (Sandwiches)

All come on fresh baked Italian Bread and served with Sea Salt Kettle-cooked potato chips

Grilled Italian Sausage
Sauteed bell peppers, white onions and topped with Parmesan Cheese.
Hot Pastrami
Steamed and thinly sliced Pastrami served with a spicy mustard.
Chicken Parmesan
Tender breast of chicken topped with fresh Marinara and Parmesan cheese.
Home-made Meatball Marinara
Freshly made Italian meatballs topped with a warm Marinara sauce and Parmesan cheese.

Calzone

Calzones
Made to order stuffed with Lefty's Marinara, Mozzarella and any two toppings of your choice.  Then hand pinched, baked to perfection, and covered in garlic butter and imported Parmesan cheese.  Try adding our all natural whole milk Ricotta cheese for a truly traditional creation.

Straight from Boston's North End (Pastas)

Spaghetti
With Marinara sauce
Sausage Cacciatore
Fresh Italian sausage simmered in our own Marinara sauce with bell peppers, roasted garlic, mushrooms and sliced ripe olives.  Served with your choice of pasta.
Chicken Parmesan
Served with your choice of pasta and topped with our own Marinara Sauce.
Cheese Tortellini
Topped with creamy pesto sauce and finished with shredded imported Parmesan cheese.
Build Your Own Pasta
Pasta Choices:
Spaghetti
Cheese Tortellini

Sauce Choices:
Marinara
Alfredo
Creamy Pesto

Salads

Boston Garden Salad
Chopped lettuce, cherry tomatoes, red peppers, red onions, carrots and green house cucumbers.
Mediterranean Salad
Our garden salad (minus the carrots) topped with whole milk Feta cheese, Kalamata olives, and pepperoncinis.
Caesar Salad
Chopped Romaine lettuce, cherry tomatoes, shredded parmesan cheese, and garlic croutons. Dressing always comes on the side.

Specialty Pizzas

Medium 12" (serves 1-2)
Large 16" (serves 2-3)
Wicked Large 19" (serves 3-5)

Della Magia
Sautéed mushrooms, fresh garlic and baby spinach with homemade white butter sauce, shredded Mozzarella and Asiago cheeses.
North End
Our homemade Italian meatballs with puddles of house red sauce and Ricotta cheese on top of our shredded Mozzarella, lightly sprinkled with aged shredded Parmesan and oregano.
Harvard Yard
Quartered artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers and fresh baby spinach laid atop our house red sauce, shredded Mozzarella, lightly sprinkled with Feta and Asiago cheese.
Tomato Pesto
Fresh tomatoes, shredded Mozzarella and our signature pesto sauce topped with Asiago cheese.
'1912'
Lefty's red sauce, shredded Mozzarella, mushrooms, green peppers, white onions and California black olives, Lefty's house recipe pepperoni and natural style Italian sausage.
Mediterranean
Fresh sliced tomatoes, baby spinach, Feta and shredded Mozzarella cheese on top of our house white sauce and lightly sprinkled with grated Asiago and oregano.
Chicken Ranch
Ranch sauce and Napa Valley extra virgin olive oil, shredded Mozzarella, fresh chicken breast and our fresh cooked Applewood-smoked country bacon. Sprinkled with oregano and aged shredded Parmesan cheese.
Hawaiian BBQ
BBQ sauce with shredded Mozzarella, fresh BBQ chicken and pineapple, sprinkled with aged Parmesan
Meat Lovah
Our biggest seller! Shredded Mozzarella, our house recipe pepperoni, Italian sausage, fresh Applewood smoked country bacon and our homemade Italian meatballs, all gently placed on top of our famous red sauce.
The Patriot
Pesto Sauce topped with pepperoni, Canadian Bacon, pineapple, jalapenos, Mozarella cheese and Italian seasoning.
Margherita
An East coast classic made the old fashion way. Our hand tossed pizza crust with our classic hand-crushed pomodoro sauce, 100% olive oil, fresh Mozzarella and a chiffonade of fresh basil leaves.

Build Your Own Pizza

All BYO Pizzas start with the Classic Cheese, Mozzarella on Marinara. Add up to 5 toppings max for the best custom flavor experience!

Gluten Free Crust available in 12" size

Other sauce choices: White sauce, Garlic Sauce, BBQ Sauce, Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Pesto, Ranch

Medium 12" (serves 1-2)

Large 16" (serves 2-3)

Wicked Large 19" (serves 3-5)

Toppings

5 thoughts on “Food Menu”

  2. Im from hubardston and looking for a true classic Turkey cheese with all the fixings grinder. Do you only have hot ones,
    Very excited to see place fronts Shrewsbury. Wicked awesome

Comments are closed.